Flower City Union to NPSL!

Today is finally the day. It was the worst kept secret for months that Flower City Union was leaving NISA, but that announcement has already been made. Today it finally became clear where they were ending up. They are moving to the National Premier Soccer League (hereafter referred to as the NPSL). There are a few positives and some negatives to this, so here we are to explain it all.
Before going into the positives and negatives, I think we need to start with some logistics. First of all, however this is positioned, it is a drop from Professional to Amateur. According to Wikipedia, NPSL is a “semi-professional league, comprising some teams that have paid players and some that are entirely amateur.” I do not know any speculation for the future, however this season it is intended that FCU be an amateur team. Being in NPSL however means the door is kept open that they could pay players in the future. This is a change from last year where NISA was the third tier of the US soccer pyramid and completely professional, while FCU will now be in the fourth tier and the team will be completely amateur (potentially facing professional opposition). The season is much shorter than NISA was, running from May to July (10-12 games), with playoffs after this point. The league is much more regionalized, rather than nationwide, but I’ll go into that more specifically later. Changing leagues also means that FCU no longer qualifies for the US Open Cup, so that historical tournament will have to be missed out on this summer.
Prior to this announcement, it was my understanding that dropping to an amateur team is intended to be temporary, as investors are sought to be able to move back to a professional model. However, this information came to me when I was sure that the team would be moving to USL League Two, and that investment was required to move up to League One. Owning a team is incredibly expensive, so moving to any sort of professional league will require additional funding.
The Positives
While NPSL is a semi-professional league, they at least has the correct goal of “providing our members with a sustainable business model.” NISA teams lose incredible amounts of money and that was not a sustainable league to be in, even after having won the championship. As it stands, I have been told the budget will be very competitive, and while FCU will not be paying players, they intend to put out a top-quality product and gameday experience. I am told that the “stadium environment will be better” and that the gameday will be “all the things [we] tried to implement… last year and then some.” So while it may not be a professional team, it is not intended to be an amateur product.
The other main positive for NPSL besides being in a more sustainable league is that the teams they are playing will be much more regionalized. Rather than having games all the way across the country, they will be in the Great Lakes Conference along with Akron City FC, Cleveland SC, and FC Columbus (in Akron, Cleveland and Columbus, Ohio, respectively), Erie Commodores and Steel City FC (in Erie and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, respectively), and Carpathia FC (outside Detroit, Michigan). For their budget, this will significantly reduce the travel costs, as last season required a lot of flying and hotels. Just to win the championship, you would be shocked to know the cost that added to the budget for 3 extra games (think tens of thousands of dollars). As a fan, you can also easily see an away game if you want. And while I liked the uniqueness of playing as Salt City Union in Auburn, that will no longer be happening this year. All home games will be played in Rochester, so fans won’t have to travel unless they want to attend an away game.
The shorter schedule also includes the possibility that the team will play a number of friendlies. While to my knowledge nothing has been confirmed yet, that is being discussed and is intended to supplement the shorter season. I know teams that have been brought up include teams outside of the NPSL conference, along with teams that are in other leagues. But what will this shorter schedule cost you, the fan? Last year, season tickets cost $150 for General Admission. Looking at other teams in NPSL that have ticket information released we can get a general idea of what to expect:
FC Monmouth - $35, plays at a town park
Kingston Stockade - $40, plays at a college
FC Motown - $50, plays at a college
Steel City - $64 (bleachers, men’s) to $190 (non-bleachers, men’s and women’s)
Bristol Rhythm - $60, $124, $250 depending on seating/package
I think it would be fair to expect tickets to fall somewhere in the $75-90 range, and would include both Flower City Union and 1872 tickets. The teams with cheaper tickets also play at cheaper venues. FCU will still be playing at the stadium downtown, and still have rent to pay, so tickets cannot be dirt cheap. As I have been told and stated before, they still plan to put out a professional gameday experience, so staying at that stadium was a must. In good news, another thing that isn’t confirmed but seems like a great idea is there will be a “bunch of different tiers with different things at each tier”, meaning that if you buy a ticket and say a jersey, you’d get a small discount rather than buying each separately. While it won't be happening this year, in the future your season ticket could also buy your ticket to an Amateur Cup match. While this doesn’t have the name recognition of the US Open Cup, it seems as if FCU would be able to get a berth into it. Last year, the Rochester Lazers, an amateur women’s side (featuring 4 or 5 Flower City 1872 women) made it to the finals of the competition.
Finally, I think it is a good thing to be out of the NISA branding. While Flower City won the championship last year, that company is nothing but issues. Last season teams like Club de Lyon barely made it through the year, after allegations of not paying their players, staff, or venue, and rumors they were propped up by the league. I have confirmation of bills not being paid to multiple teams and vendors, but as this is not public information, you’ll have to decide for yourself whether you trust me or not, as I will not be putting that out there. There were also allegations that NISA front office staff has not been paid. All you have to do is Google the owner of the league and companies he’s involved in, to find lots of shady goings-on (most notably from when they tried to buy Sheffield Wednesday, and there were tons of fraud rumours swirling).
NISA does have its own amateur league, NISA Nation, but just being out from under that branding can only help long-term. The league had its annual meeting at the beginning of December and a schedule was supposed to be announced soon after, but it was only on February 16th that they announced the teams that will be playing, and it's only 9, far short of the 12+ they promised. They have announced a few new teams, but there are a lot of questions remain has to how these teams will actually be able to be in a professional league. Rumors have been circulating for a while from Dan Creel (Protagonist Soccer) that USSF is scrutinizing the league for re-sanctioning and auditing every NISA team in person.
Negatives
It’s impossible to ignore the big negative: there will no longer be a professional soccer team in Rochester, at least for the time being. Moving to a semi-professional league will still have quality play, but it will mostly be a lot younger, college-aged kids. While there is hope that some of the players from last season could return, any who did would be ones that did not find a team elsewhere, so it will not be any of the top performers from last season.
However, to the best of my knowledge, it is intended that head coach Jordan Sullivan will be returning this year and will be coaching the women’s team along with the men’s. FCU had momentum going through the summer, with crowds increasing, and finally got press coverage when they went to and won the NISA Championship. Dropping down to an amateur status can only hurt this image, as a lot of fans will be turned off that they are not professional. They can still put out a professional product, and still have a professional gameday experience, but a casual fan looking to go to a soccer game in Rochester may decide not to because it is not a professional team. The other negative around this is that it is for an indeterminate amount of time. While the team has always been intended to be a professional team, without more fans or investors, meaning more money, it may not happen.
It has always been an open secret that they were probably leaving the league, however most of the speculation was that they would be moving to USL League Two. There was even an announcement scheduled for January 11th at 10AM PST. That would have aligned with the rest of USL’s announcements, which all come at 1PM EST. Whatever that announcement was was canceled, and now the NPSL announcement has been made.
Note from the writer
If I had to guess why NPSL was chosen over USL, I’d have to guess it all comes down to money. In order to leave NISA, Chattanooga FC had to pay $1 million. While I’ve heard that that wouldn’t be the case for FCU (I’ve heard multiple different reasons, either because they didn’t have a contract, were dropping to amateur, or were given the go-ahead by NISA), it is in NISA’s best interest to retain their league champions. USL is a direct competitor to NISA, so going there would have created headaches for the league. It seems the safest route was to just avoid upsetting NISA and go to NPSL, as even if FCU were in their rights to leave, lawyers to prove that could cost a fortune. The quality difference between NPSL and USL League Two is probably not noticeable, and while fans in Rochester may know the USL brand, it is also completely amateur, whereas NPSL allows the potential to be professional. But again, it all comes down to money.
Before moving to Rochester, I had season tickets to FC Buffalo for 7 seasons. These were amateur seasons in the NPSL. I always had a great time at these games, and I watched them build a following and a better gameday experience. There will certainly be naysayers about this move, and I myself certainly have my reservations, but I guarantee the games will be just as fun to watch and attend, and I can only hope this regrouping is better for the club and the city in the long run.
Did Flower City Union make the right choice, leaving NISA & joining NPSL?
Yes
No
Too early to tell
There's not a big difference between the two




Comments