top of page

State of The Union

Writer: Rick Lewis
Rick Lewis
Dec 24, 2024
11 min read



It’s been a while since I’ve written anything about Flower City Union/1872, and last summer as I stopped writing recap articles, that gap just grew. The season may have ended over 5 months ago, but they have not sat back in the off-season, there’s been a lot of happenings off the field for next season, so to finish out 2024 it seemed as good a time as any to put out those updates. This will be a long article, as there’s a lot to cover, so it’ll be broken down into sections.


Flower City Union


The men’s side of things saw the biggest change in their short history. Going from 2023 NISA champions in a professional league (let’s say professional as in “players were paid” and not as in a league that was “competent or skilled” [https://www.hudsonriverblue.com/death-of-a-league-nisa-no-longer-sanctioned/]) to a regional amateur league was always going to have its growing pains. From the outside looking in, it appears to me that that drop went mostly fine. Their first home match of the season set a new attendance record for the club (1,172). Attendances in sports are always slightly inflated, with free tickets given to groups or people as promotion or just higher in order to sound better, but this was definitely growth on last season. Unfortunately, that growth was not as sustained as it should have been. Through no fault of the club’s, their schedule sucked.

Based on rumors swirling in the prior off-season, along with an announcement scheduled by the club and USL League Two for 10am one morning last off-season (the time USL makes team announcements) and the fact that those announcements were canceled, it seems likely that they were planning to move to that league. Based on the fact that Chattanooga FC had to pay a $1 million fee to exit NISA, it seems likely that FCU’s failure to join USL had something to do with NISA. The issue with this and why I talk about it 9 months later, FCU were not announced as joining NPSL until very close to the season beginning. This led to a terrible schedule where a home game was followed by 5 away games, then the final 4 home games in just 10 days. I think this is why their attendances figures were not sustained with the high of the opener, although they were respectable for an amateur team and higher than away games they went to. There were also intended to be friendlies to have a few more matches for season ticket holders, but they never materialized. Another thing beyond their control was that they ordered new bespoke kits for the 2024 season, but the home kits never arrived until the very last game, so fans have only seen them once.

On the field, while no one expected FCU in 2023 to win the championship (most of the season the playoffs weren’t even an expectation), 2024 had a much more difficult playoff picture. NPSL is a regional league with a lot more teams all over the country, so just making the playoffs had to be the expectation. They may have kept it late, not sealing a playoff spot until the final game, but that led to an exciting finish, even if they did lose the resulting playoff game. On the reverse side, this season also had one of the lowest lows of the franchise, when they allowed 5 goals from the same player (and almost all the exact same manner) against Akron City. As a completely pointless note, in their 21 seasons, the Rochester (Raging) Rhinos allowed 1 ever hat trick, and 0 people scored 4 or more. So to allow that, was certainly a low point.


Flower City 1872


The women’s team had a mostly complete turnaround from their inaugural season. Their first season saw them with a -24 goal differential, 1 win, and 5 losses. It was not what they had in mind for their first year, but the beginning of this season turned that around. The 2024 season started with 3 straight wins and a lot of promise. Unfortunately, that was the end of their winning ways and their following 5 games was 4 losses and 1 draw. Their first loss was particularly harsh, as they should have beaten Steel City in Pittsburgh, but it was 88 degrees and sunny, and they only traveled with 1 substitute. They just couldn’t stand up to the home team. I do not consider this a low point, this was just a disappointment because I saw their potential. The low point of the season was losing to FC Berlin, a game they should have dominated. The high point of their season though was probably Delaney Tellex’s hat trick in a 6-0 demolishing of FC Berlin at home. It was the first ever hat trick in franchise history, and their only win by more than 1 goal. On the field in the coming season, they have already announced a lot of exciting returning players, including the aforementioned Tellex, Jailyn Parrotte (who led a strong defense and played every minute last season), both goalkeepers (Sam Haley and Cate Burns) and Maya Ikewood (another 8 game player). I’ve not looked into their other signings, but all play at D1 colleges. Next season seems to have retained some of their strongest players along with bringing in exciting new ones.

Next season will see Flower City 1872 in a new league, under the USL banner in their USL-W league. Their competition from last year of Steel City and FC Buffalo have moved over to this league as well, along with the only other currently announced team, Pittsburgh Riveters (affiliated with the Riverhounds). It seems as if this will be tough competition (especially the Riveters, and they have never beaten FC Buffalo), but this move can surely only be seen as a good thing. First of all, the USL name meant something in Rochester. For most of their existence the Rhinos were under the USL banner. It can’t hurt to bring that name back to the city. Also, as someone who loves stats, I have always been annoyed by the patchwork keeping of them that UWS did, whereas I have dealt with someone from the USL who had historical Rhinos stats still after they’ve been gone for 7 years. I just feel like USL has to be a better run organization (yes, I am basing my entire analysis on this small fact). The one interesting rule change for the women will be regarding substitutions. Last season they were allowed subs based on college rules, and women subbed off in one half could return in the second half. That helped them in that hot game in Pittsburgh with only 1 sub, however this year teams are allowed 7 subs and no one allowed to return. Hopefully they have a bigger bench and are able to travel with more players consistently next year.

Off the field, 1872 has announced their coaching for the year. USL has stricter standards for coaches than other leagues, so the coach needs to have a UEFA B license (or a C working towards the B). They filled this position with Antonio La Gamba. Last season he was a player for FCU and an assistant coach for 1872, so this is a step up. The fact that he was assistant last year and has the required license means he’d been planning on this, so hopefully he continues to build on what Jordan Sullivan did last year (and I can only assume he will, as he played under and coached with him). Also returning to Rochester is Kyle Nelson, who played every every single game in FCU’s championship season. He clearly has what it takes to be a player (he was voted player of the season by his 2023 teammates) and one can only assume he can be a good addition as an assistant coach. Also, as a fan, I can only hope he’ll lace up his boots as a ringer for FCU. 1872 also has their own bespoke kits coming from Hummel. I have seen mock-ups of different designs, and I will tease the fact that the one that is getting a test kit produced has some great stories that inspired it. You’ll see.


The Leagues


Flower City 1872 are moving to a whole new league, but the Union are staying in NPSL. As for what’s currently known for the women, their toughest rival from the last two seasons (FC Buffalo) and a team they really could have beaten twice (Steel City FC) are making the move with them. I hope Erie moves as well, but I do not know if that’s in the cards. I am excited to see them play at Highmark Stadium, a soccer-specific stadium where the Riverhounds make their home, but that’s also troubling as the Riveters will surely have a strong team. There must be more teams yet to be announced in the division, probably a mix of new and moving teams. It won’t be easy, but I predict that this is the year they finally beat FC Buffalo and are competitive through the whole season. They have almost 2 dozen women already committed, and it’s an exciting mix of newcomers and returning players.

The men on the other hand are traditionally slower to commit than the women. Last I heard, they were talking to both returning players and new, but nowhere near the numbers committed like with the women. This is not a cause for concern, this is just the difference between the men and women. Both teams have open tryouts on January 4, so there will be more of a picture of their numbers and who might be on both teams after that point. The men’s division is slightly more troubling. Steel City FC and Akron City FC have both moved to USL League Two. It’s also been reported for a long time that Cleveland SC will not be returning next season (however they are holding tryouts, they post on social media, and they commented on reporter Michael Battista’s post “we are still here”). This is troubling because the division was not the largest to begin with, with it being split in two east/west sections. Having the division split in half meant last season FCU traveled to Southern Indiana, so this year could see them returning there and going to Michigan (as a fan, I like this, but those are long bus rides for players). It seems likely they will have about 10 regular season games, playing 5 teams home and away. But with two teams who last season finished above them in the division now in another league, that leaves them in a good position to place higher.

Dealing with amateur teams rather than professional, a majority of the players will surely be made up of college athletes. Last year 1872 had some women in their 30s, but that is the outlier. Having college players means you are stuck in a timeline already dictated by schools. Both of these teams could really use a preseason next year, to get to know each other and start training together. While the front office planning has never stopped, it’s yet to be seen if a timeline will allow for this. The 2024 men’s 0-2 start and giving up 8 goals while scoring 0 shows how much they could have used a preseason. It will also be nice from a fan’s perspective if there are friendlies for both teams. 1872 has never had a preseason or friendly for fans to attend, and FCU did not have any last season, so those would be nice additions for more games next season. I know these were being discussed last year, and again this off-season, so hopefully some come to fruition.

On an unrelated note, I didn’t know where else to throw it, but I commented earlier that USL League Two seemed to be on the table at one point. With the women in the USL-W, it seems like that would be a nice fit for the men as well, and it would be easier on management. Reading their 26 page gameday operations manual, USL League Two and USL-W have the exact same standards. It should be a goal of the team to be under the same umbrella, and it seems like it would be easier from an operations standpoint.


Off the Field


The front office has seen some changes since the teams last kicked a ball. This summer GM Casey Caitlin announced that he was leaving the team. Thankfully, he reversed that decision, and has been working full time ever since. While I wished him the best leaving, it really would have hurt the team to lose him. He works more than full time on both teams, and he’s been integral in building the team since he took over in 2023. When he announced he was leaving, so too did head coach Jordan Sullivan. After coaching the men to a championship in 2023 (the second youngest head coach to do this in men’s US soccer since the 1960s), he took on a role in charge of both teams last year. Both teams had their problems with losing streaks, but both did well overall. He will be a big loss this season. Antonio and Kyle will hopefully be good replacements for 1872, but it’s unsure as of yet who will replace him for FCU. They haven’t announced a coach yet, so maybe he can be talked into returning.

The 2023 seasons for both clubs started terribly. The men had lost 4 straight without scoring a goal, while the women lost their inaugural game 6-0. As the person who had overseen the building of these teams, GM Andrew Hoyt was the one to fall on his sword. It’s understandable that they had to axe the top. In retrospect, he clearly helped construct a great team that will go down in history. Well, it appears he is back this year. I don’t know in what capacity; it seems to be part-time assisting with things, but his knowledge can’t hurt and can only help to lighten the load for Casey. I was also told over the last 2 years that he was good at getting sponsorships, so I won’t complain about having him back if that is true.

For fans, season tickets were recently announced, and they are cheaper this season. I was told they “tried to keep it cheap this year” and they “want a really strong season ticket base”. Last season, before schedules were announced, comparing their stadium and amenities to similar clubs, their prices seemed fine. However with the schedule, it really did turn out too expensive. This season’s goal seems to be price lower, then deliver more. They aren’t skimping on a gameday experience, as they are doing little purchases to make a more professional atmosphere. This year, the 4th official will have an electronic board for substitutions and stoppage time. Just a little purchase to seem more professional. They’ve also announced that the player benches will have coverings this year. This is nice for a player in the sun or rain, but also an additional place for team branding and sponsorship.

One off-season move that I can’t foresee the outcome of is a strategic partnership with the Golisano Institute. I’m unsure what exactly this means, but I have seen the first little bit of that partnership and I liked it. Flower City had a presence at Boot Room Pub for the MLS finals recently. They had a table set up with little giveaways. They had interns from the Golisano Institute who were walking around the pub, signing up people for a jersey giveaway, and trying to tell people about the team. It was a nice start for people who might not normally know that information. And as someone who does know that information, I can confirm they did a good job when trying to sell me on the team.


Conclusion


Last season had a lot of changes, and some growing pains. I would like to see both teams playing in professional leagues some day, but for now, they’re doing what they can in amateur leagues and doing it right. They are building the team and trying to build a fanbase. I am really excited for what I think will be a great year for Flower City 1872. I also think that if the men can recruit like the women, Flower City Union has a great chance of winning their division. While not everything over the past year was positive from a fan’s point of view, I think the overall trend was in the right direction, so I have faith they’ll continue to grow and build in that right direction. It’s exciting to be near the start of something that’s got limitless possibilities if they continue as they have.

Comments


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page