top of page

Flower City Union's 2024 NPSL Season Preview

Writer: Rick Lewis
Rick Lewis
Apr 21, 2024
10 min read



2024 brings a new league, a new status, and a new team for last season's NISA champions, Flower City Union. There are a lot of unknowns at this time, as before the first game there will have been no open practices to attend or any pre-season scrimmages. So, while I can make educated guesses based on what I've seen so far, in reality things may be far different. However, I'm in the best place I can be to give a preview of this upcoming season, so that's the best you'll get. First the specifics: Flower City Union has moved to the National Premier Soccer League (NPSL). This means teams are an amateur status, so while they could offer things like housing to attract out of town talent, none of the players can be paid. NPSL's intentions in the coming seasons is to eventually convert to a league with both amateur and professional teams, or to start their own professional league. The NPSL playoffs last season had different qualifications per Conference, where each Conference winner reached the playoffs. However, some Conferences had 2, 3, or even 4 teams qualify. As for FCU's team itself, the only returning players from last season are Ryan Curtis and Dylan Ruiz. I wanted to touch on the fact that these are the only two returning players, however we will have separate coverage devoted to the entire team and a preview from Flower City Union's side. There are 7 teams in FCU's Great Lakes Conference this year, with 2 being brand new and 5 having been established in the NPSL before.

As for who FCU will be facing this season, there are some unknown quantities, and it seems most interesting to start with these. The most unknown of these is Niagara 1812. Niagara was not announced as being part of the league until March 7 (with a women's team having been announced about a month prior). Over a month and a half later, after they have played a game, there is still very little information about the team. They have posted nothing personal on their social media, only logos and schedules for things like the season and tryouts. They played a game last evening, and while their Instagram Story had a graphic for the game being upcoming, it did not give any information about a line-up or result (they went down 1-0, then pulled 2 goals back late, and then blew it in the final minutes, losing 3-2 against United Premier Soccer League [UPSL] side Upstate United FC). Their Twitter account has not posted anything for 6 weeks, and their Bio is only about their women's team. They do not appear to have a website. They had a LinkedIn post looking for an intern, and stated they have between 11 and 50 employees, but even 11 at this point seems to be quite a stretch (for example, fellow newcomer Southern Indiana's states they have between 2 and 10). There was also a post on a website called Ask For Funding in 2023. They were looking to raise $200,000, which would be a very respectable budget in this league. However, it also states there will be a “Website presence for all our Partners” and “Social Media presence for all our Partners”, neither of which appears to have happened. This site also says they will be “streaming live games”, but based on the rest of what I've seen, I will be at D'youville University on May 29th, as it's only a 75 minute drive and I do not at all trust that the game will be streamed.

The next unknown is Southern Indiana Guardians FC. This team actually does have an online presence, however it's very odd. The issue with this team is that they appear to be playing in both the NPSL and UPSL. It's unknown whether this is one team in two leagues, two separate teams, or one large pool of players that can be chosen for either. Everything leads me to believe this is the same team in two different leagues, or a large pool of players:

  • Both teams were announced on the same day

  • A lot of their posts have logos for both leagues

  • All of their posts are the same wording for both leagues

  • Tryouts mention both leagues

  • Season tickets are for both leagues, etc

Their presence in the league is less worrying than Niagara 1812's though. They were announced back in October 2023 and post prolifically on social media. All of their player announcements have the UPSL logo, so it's unclear whether that is the only team with signed players, but that team has so far started out with 2 wins to begin their season. They've also posted looking for fans who are willing to give players lodging for the summer. While that means a smaller budget for the team, as enticing out-of-town players with lodging is not something they are doing, it does appear they are trying to recruit outside of their commuting area. Southern Indiana are over 9 hours away, so it's a good sign that their UPSL games are being streamed on YouTube, as it means there's a good chance their NPSL game against FCU will be as well.

The most worrying team FCU will face this season will probably be Steel City FC. Starting a season with back to back games against last season's Conference winner is not ideal (especially after the slow start that FCU saw last season). Last year, Steel City did not lose a single game, going 10-0-2 and averaging only 1 goal against per game. Their only loss of the season came in the playoffs to Tulsa Athletic, who went on to win the NPSL National Championship. Steel City has a massive men's and women's program with over a dozen total teams, including youth and development. Last season's roster for the men's NPSL team had 35 players. While their website does not have a roster for this year (and I don't feel like comparing their Open Cup line-up to last season's), it's a safe bet that it will be a lot of returning players, and ones that have played together for years in their development system. The hardest part about lower-league soccer is building and maintaining a cohesive team, rather than having to rebuild every season. Steel City seems able to overcome this obstacle. They have played 1 meaningful match this season, and it was a 1-0 defeat to NISA's Michigan Stars in the US Open Cup, which is a great result against a professional team. Last season Steel City broadcast all their men's and women's games on YouTube, and having watched Flower City 1872 play against them, they have high-quality announcers and a good feed. They also draw a good crowd, with over 1,100 at their Open Cup match.

The award for the team with the worst logo in the Conference goes to Michigan Rangers FC. Last season, Michigan ended the season in second place, with 8 wins, 3 losses, and 1 draw. Second place Michigan hosted fellow Conference member Cleveland SC in the playoffs, and lost 1-0. They have a large pool of players to pull from, as they have multiple development teams, going down to even ages 2 to 5. Back to March 1st they were already announcing players for this season. The players they have already announced are from all over the world and outside their state (Ireland, Morocco, Spain, and New York). They have said their full squad will be announced in May, and it's a safe bet they will be another top contender this year, based on all these factors. Last season, their games were all streamed on YouTube, and while the video quality was very good, there was no commentating.

Erie Commodores are yet another club with men's, women's, and youth teams. It's a bit of a surprise to me that Erie finished in the bottom half of the Conference last year, with 5 wins, 6 losses, and 1 draw. They have not qualified for the playoffs in the last 4 seasons. They used to come to Western New York and beat their rivals FC Buffalo almost every single season though. They've been on a downward swing as of late, with losing records in their last 4 seasons, but they should never be counted out, as they have won their conference 5 times in their 14 years of existence. They have not announced a roster yet, however they have started an academy in coordination with Spain's Villarreal, so they are committed to building their development. They had a pretty nice sized supporter's group, the Armada, in the past, but they haven't posted anything on Twitter since the 2021 season and Facebook since the 2022 season, so it seems like their support may have waned. If I had to guess, I would say they will be middle of the road again this season, but because of their commitment to developing youth players, they are surely going to build successful teams in the future, and this year may be the start. Their games were streamed to YouTube last season with great quality, multiple camera angles, and based on the women's match I watched very good commentating.

Akron City FC finished last season in 6th out of 7th place in their conference. Their 3 wins, 8 losses, and 1 draw in 2023 is the lowest of the teams FCU will be facing this season (aside from the two new teams that have yet to play a season). While their record and points total are lower than Erie's was, they had ended the season on the same goal differential, so Erie's 2 more wins was not that much better. Akron seems to be a weaker team as they do not appear to have that large of a budget. Unlike the powerhouses in this Conference, they do not have a development academy or teams, but run Youth Clinics, much like FCU does. However, they also have a unique fan request, as fans can “sponsor” a player. Their website has 500 different donation amount requests, and I'm unsure what fans receive at most levels, but so far $11,600 has been pledged. For donations around $300 you can sponsor a player and will receive one of their game worn jerseys, with this money going towards helping pay for team travel and post-game meals. The team has a supporters group, the Rubber City Underground, and while they appear to post a lot on social media, they were only formed in the middle of last season, so I can't really get a gauge of what they are like. Hoppin' Frog is one of Akron's sponsors, and they make amazing beers, so I will absolutely be there for the away game on June 15th. They did not stream games to YouTube, but they did stream on the defunct Eleven Sports, so I do not know the quality of their feeds, but at least they did stream their games. They have a pre/post-game/sideline reporter; he gave updates during matches, he wore a suit, and he had a microphone, so they are far more professional than I have acted, and I would expect a good product to watch for away FCU fans.

The final team FCU will be facing is Cleveland SC. Finishing in third place in the Conference last season with a record of 6 wins, 4 losses, and 2 draws was enough to secure an away game playoff spot. Their record was much worse than number 2 seeded Michigan, but that didn't matter as they upset Michigan, in Michigan, 1-0. They then, unsurprisingly, lost 2-0 to Steel City. Cleveland has only been in existence for 5 seasons, taking 2nd in their first season, then winning the conference the next 3 straight. Last season's 3rd place finish is their lowest in their history. They have not yet announced any players, but last week did announce coaching and front office staff, so they are hopefully a bit behind schedule. Their social media did have a great burn though, when one of their former players signed for Michigan, and they told him he'll always be welcome back on the winning team. Their website has not been updated since 2019, so that is strange, but they are active on social media, so it's not worrying. All their games last season were streamed on YouTube, with great quality video and commentating. They have a supporters section with flags and orange smoke bombs after goals, so FCU's Local 585 is gonna have to step it up to outdo them.

And now we come to the point where I make reasonable assumptions and predictions for the season. In a few months from now I will either look like a genius or an idiot, but by showing my work I can at least stand by how I came to these conclusions. First, as a fan, I will want to watch/record every single game. To me, YouTube is the best platform for streaming, as it's simple on every single device, and the games live there forever. Four of the seven teams (Cleveland, Erie, Michigan, Steel City) streamed to YouTube last season, with Southern Indiana streaming their UPSL matches, Akron having streamed to ElevenSports, and Niagara 1812 stating they would stream games. I would predict every one of these teams besides Niagara will stream their home games. I know FCU doesn't play at Cleveland or Michigan, but this could be important for playoff viewing. I just don't trust that Niagara has their shit together enough to stream games based on what I've seen thus far. I do expect every team (aside from Niagara) to have great social media presences, making this league and its news very easy to follow. While I think Niagara may be a bit of a problem child, I don't see this league having anywhere near the issues that NISA had, so things should run smoothly. As for on the field, it is going to be hard. It's going to be especially tough starting a new team with players who may still be stuck at college for the opener, and starting off with home and home games against Steel City. I predict that the team will need fans' help to keep them on track after a potential 0-2 start to the season, and fans cannot afford to give up after a rough start. I have full confidence in Head Coach Jordan Sullivan's ability to turn a team around. Last season he told us to give the team time to gel, and he was right. The start of this season will be rough, but I trust his ability and that of his strong coaching staff and their relentless recruiting/scouting. For my prediction, I think the table will be very similar to last year, with Steel City winning, followed by Michigan and Cleveland right behind. Flower City Union should be able to fit into that third, or potentially second spot. It's unclear how many playoff spots the Great Lakes Conference will have, but playoffs should absolutely be Flower City Union's goal, and they seem on paper to be on better footing than some of their established opponents.

Comments


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page