top of page

Flower City 1872: Losing Streak

Writer: Rochester Soccer News
Rochester Soccer News
Jun 22, 2024
5 min read

The 2024 season has been one that has turned around Flower City 1872. Whereas last year they had been expected to lose and even a goal was a small victory, after their start to this season, mentality has been that they should win. After a hard loss at Steel City FC (due to a number of overlapping circumstances) they went to FC Berlin last night, and the game should have been an expected win. Based on what was on the field and their prior performances though, not only was a loss disappointing, but I'd come to view it as unacceptable.

It seemed as if the game had started out 1872's way, as for the first 3 minutes the ball had never even entered their own half. After a 6-0 thrashing of Berlin in Rochester, it seemed as if the game got off to an immediately good start. However, it almost immediately changed after that, with Berlin putting on the pressure through the 5th and 6th minutes. Delaney Tellex, who was missed last week, broke Berlin's pressure with a strong play to win a free kick, leading to 1872's first shot on goal, easily into the hands of the keeper. 1872 continued strong with shots on goal in the 13th minute after a pass to Niyah Rosado, then in the 16th minute after a great long pass to Tellex. Perhaps their best chance of the opening half came in the 24th minute, when they finally had a good string of possession. The ball was passed to Caitlin Nelson, who took a long, arcing shot. It dropped perfectly, but the keeper was just slightly tall enough to grab it from entering under the crossbar.

It really was a game of back and forth, as FC Berlin looked far better than they had only a week prior in Rochester. In the 16th minute they had a corner kick which required being saved off the line by the 1872 defender. The defense of Maria Karipidis, Courtney Carter, and Jailyn Parrotte were great as usual. Whenever a ball got behind them, they were fast enough to get back and keep the ball out of trouble. The performance of the rest of the team was hit or miss, but I have nothing bad to say about any of them, or goalkeeper Sam Haley. The 26th minute saw back to back saves by Haley, who while she didn't have to make many saves in the game, was a big part of it, and that's my first big criticism. Contrary to most other games, a lot of play was set up through Haley. The ball was constantly sent back through her, rather than pressing forward.

After a scoreless first half, 1872 hadn't really been troubled about FC Berlin scoring a goal, but they also only had a smattering of chances, never appearing too threatening either. In the 55th minute they had their first shot of the second half, after some defensive pressure led to a turnover and another shot by Tellex. Berlin however went right back down, and after stealing the ball of their own, put it right into the 1872 net. Thankfully the goal was deemed offsides, but having watched in realtime and not the replay yet, I like the call, but I was not convinced it was the correct one.

1872 did have some pressure, as the 70th minute had shots on goal that had to be cleared off the line by the Berlin defense. In the 77th minute, the ball was fed through to Emma Herrman who got a shot on goal that ended up being a nice save, tipping it out for a corner kick. The resulting corner fell to Tellex, but her shot with her left foot had no power on it. The 79th minute was the final real offensive chance for 1872, and also the turning point in the game, with a very poor refereeing decision. Tellex, a defender, and the keeper were all racing for a ball on the edge of the 18 yard box. The defender did not try to get the ball at all and slammed Tellex out of the way just inside the box. What should have been a penalty kick, wasn't even called a foul, and Tellex had to be subbed out injured 3 minutes later after she was finally helped up. While they did have a shot that was tipped off the crossbar with 6 minutes left, it was FC Berlin that got on the board a minute later. A deflected shot from the end line looped up and over Haley, and a sprinting Berlin attacker escorted it over the line.

While my anger over the loss has cooled off overnight, I do have some criticisms over Flower City 1872's play. This should have been a game that was won, especially considering Berlin's history of not winning games, and the bad defeat they were recently handed at 1872's hands. I'm not going to criticize the players for not trying, but there were some things on the field that disappointed me. I have been a big fan all season of Corynna Rotoli, but her small stature led to a lot of turnovers due to balls being just outside her reach, or just too far that she didn't have the speed to catch them. The team really missed Chloe DeLyser in attack, and while Tellex had the speed, Herrmann and Taylor Wingerden were not enough of a match-up with her to capitalize on that. In the midfield, Niyah Rosado was not strong enough to make great passes or to take shots at the net. On the other hand, I would like to compliment high schooler Finn Cregan. I liked her performance against Steel City, and thought she was even better tonight, and well-deserving of her starting position.

My biggest criticism though has to be for the tactics of head coach Jordan Sullivan. Last year, when Flower City Union started out with 5 straight defeats, I did not think it was due to the coaching or tactics, but some things that didn't go their way. I never contemplated that it should be a change of coaching (don't get me wrong, I am not at all saying that here either). This is just the first time I have ever questioned his tactics*. I mentioned earlier that a lot of play seemed to go back to Haley before being sent forward. While this was sometimes good to get a repositioning, I don't feel this was the game for that. FC Berlin has been a team that has trouble scoring and leaks goals, and every time 1872 sent the ball backwards, it gave them time to drop back, and wasted time on a dwindling clock. The best 1872 looked on the night were on long counter-attack attempts, and when Parrotte took the ball and pushed the whole defense forward as well, leading to sustained pressure. They shouldn't have to require the defenders to be a part of the attack, but those three have shown they have the speed to get forward and get back, and weren't allowed to do so.

If ever a game was too defensive, it was this one. But also, hindsight is 20/20. Whether in retrospect the team will look back at this loss and my criticisms as valid or not, it doesn't matter, as they just weren't good enough on the night. They've made qualifying for the playoffs just that much harder for themselves. They probably could have afforded one loss in their last 4 games, and that one has already come against the team they should have beaten. Two games against FC Buffalo will make or break their season.





*Disclaimer: Jordan Sullivan is a professional championship winning head coach, the second youngest in the last 55 years, and the youngest in the last 29. I am someone who has not played since the age of 10 and wear retro jerseys to look “cool”.


 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page